Sabji Mandi (A Food for Thought)

A common sense approach to trading.

7/23/20243 min read

A market or marketplace is a place where buyers and sellers come together to trade goods and services. Whether it's a sabji mandi (vegetable market), a clothing store, or any other retail environment, the underlying principle remains the same: a shop owner trades their assets (vegetables, clothes, etc.) to a customer in exchange for money. This everyday trading activity is governed by common sense and practical decision-making.

When you go to the local mandi to buy what you need for the next few days, you’re engaging in a common-sense approach to trading. The vendor who sells you those vegetables has inventory for perhaps a week. The main vegetable supplier for your area, the distributor, maintains a larger inventory to be sold to local vendors. This chain of middlemen can be traced back to the farmers producing the vegetables.

The common-sense goal for all these players at different levels is to "stay in business." If the price of tomatoes suddenly spikes to 200, most of us will cut down on consumption. If the price drops to 10, it doesn’t mean you’ll rush to buy large quantities because they are perishable. You’ll buy only as much as needed for your household within your budget. This is our business model as end consumers, and it helps us stay in the business of "getting daily meals."

Similarly, the local vendor also needs to stay in business by keeping enough inventory for his customers. He doesn’t hoard more tomatoes than he can sell because he knows his limitations based on market wisdom and common sense.

Parallel to Stock Market Trading

The options market, or any financial market, operates the same way. You must use the same common sense when dealing with financial instruments. Trading should be viewed as a business, with the primary goal being to stay in business. The critical requirement remains inventory management: trade quantities as per your need, not greed. Whether you trade as an end consumer, a vendor, or a distributor, don’t mix up their roles. Risk only the quantity (capital, lots, etc.) your common sense allows you to stay in the business.

Real-Life Examples

Consider Warren Buffett, one of the most successful investors of all time. He emphasizes the importance of understanding the businesses he invests in and never risks more than he can afford to lose. His strategy is akin to a vegetable vendor managing inventory based on demand and perishability.

Another example is Ray Dalio, founder of Bridgewater Associates. Dalio's principles include understanding the mechanics of the market and managing risk meticulously. He diversifies his investments, similar to how a distributor would diversify their stock to manage risk and ensure business continuity.

Risk Management Techniques

  • Setting Stop-Loss Orders: This helps limit losses by automatically selling a stock when it reaches a certain price. It's like a vendor setting a limit on how much overripe produce they are willing to keep before discarding it.

  • Diversifying Portfolios: Spreading investments across various assets reduces risk. Just as a vendor stocks multiple types of vegetables to cater to different customer needs and mitigate the risk of any one item not selling.

  • Not Over-Leveraging: Using too much borrowed money can lead to significant losses, similar to a vendor taking on too much stock without the means to sell it.

Professionalism in Trading

Trading can’t be a hobby, side job, lottery ticket, or a get-rich-quick scheme. The FnO (Futures and Options) segment exists for a reason, supporting a massive hedge fund industry. From a business perspective, FnO or any financial instrument isn't a gambler’s game. Each financial instrument has academic and professional utility, sound core basics, and mathematical models behind it. Nobel Prizes have been awarded for financial pricing models, such as the Black-Scholes model for option pricing.

Educational Resources

For those looking to deepen their understanding, consider reading books like "The Intelligent Investor" by Benjamin Graham or "Principles" by Ray Dalio. Online courses on platforms like Coursera or Zerodha Varsity offer structured learning on financial markets and trading strategies.

Conclusion

Trading can be defined as a business involving a person who is opportunistic with a killer survival instinct. Just like in the sabji mandi, the primary goal is to stay in business. This involves managing inventory wisely, understanding your role, and making decisions based on common sense and market wisdom.

Successful traders, like successful vegetable vendors, know their limitations and manage risk carefully. They do not treat trading as a hobby or a side job but as a serious business that requires discipline, knowledge, and a professional approach.

To succeed in trading, apply the same common sense you use in everyday activities like shopping at the vegetable market. Manage your inventory wisely, understand your role, and prioritize staying in business over quick profits. Trading, like any other profession, requires discipline, knowledge, and a professional approach. Stay informed, stay cautious, and most importantly, stay in the business.

assorted fruits at the market
assorted fruits at the market